UNDEX stands for underwater explosion. A charge detonated under water, such as a mine or a torpedo warhead, sends a spherical shock wave (a front of sharply raised pressure) out through the water, and leaves a bubble of high-pressure detonation gas that expands and contracts as it rises [1, 2]. How a ship is loaded, and how badly, depends mainly on the standoff distance R, the distance from the charge to the hull. For small mines and torpedo warheads, which carry about 100–300 kg of TNT (trinitrotoluene) [2], there are three zones.
Three zones, by distance from the hull
- Contact or bubble-expansion zone, R = 0–12 m. Within about 12 m the gas bubble reaches the hull directly [1, 2]. The hull takes severe combined loading from the initial shock wave and from the expansion and contraction of the bubble: a breach, tearing of the shell plating (the hull's outer skin) and severe damage around the point of the explosion [1].
- Close-distance or near-field zone, R ≈ 12–30 m. Beyond about 12 m the hull is generally out of the gas bubble's reach and is loaded mainly by the travelling shock wave [1, 2]. The pulsating gas bubble can still bend the hull as a whole (whipping). For 100 kg of TNT the peak pressure falls from about 18 MPa (megapascals) at 12 m to about 6 MPa at 30 m (Cole's formula, below [2]). Kiciński and Szturomski put close-proximity explosions at 2–20 m, with more than 8 MPa on the hull: enough to pierce it along linear cracks that follow its frames and girders (the hull's internal stiffening members, running round and along it) [2]. Such explosions also push the plating into a bulge and tear machinery and equipment from their foundations [1, 2].
- Far-field zone, R > 30 m. Explosions more than 30 m from the hull are far-field explosions [1, 2]. The hull plating is not broken, though it may be dented; instead the shock wave gives the hull structure high accelerations, which spread over practically the whole vessel and damage machinery and equipment on board, electrical equipment most of all [1, 2]. The peak pressure keeps falling with distance: for a 100 kg TNT charge it is about 6 MPa at 30 m and 3.6 MPa at 50 m [2]. Szturomski puts the limit at which a warship keeps its capabilities at about 4 MPa, with cracking of machinery and equipment casings above that, up to 8 MPa [1]. This is the zone that the shock-analysis tool listed under Provenance on the shock-mounting page simulated, and the regime addressed by shipboard shock-qualification standards such as MIL-DTL-901E (the US Navy's specification for high-impact shock testing of shipboard machinery and equipment, dated 20 June 2017, which replaced MIL-S-901D).
Peak pressure: Cole's formula
Peak shock pressure can be estimated with Cole's formula, pmax = 52.3·(m1/3/R)1.13 MPa, with m the TNT charge in kg and R the standoff in m. Cole derived it from measurements on 70–136 kg charges [2]. For 100 kg it gives about 14 MPa at 15 m, 6 MPa at 30 m and 3.6 MPa at 50 m.
What this means for shipboard equipment
Far-field shock is the shock that a mounting scheme protects equipment against. Oravont designs and analyses the shock-mounting systems that protect shipboard equipment on submarines and surface ships against UNDEX shock, and simulates mounted equipment with its SMS-Suite software. Shock-mounting design at Oravont →
References
- B. Szturomski, "The effect of an underwater explosion on a ship," Zeszyty Naukowe Akademii Marynarki Wojennej (Scientific Journal of Polish Naval Academy), vol. 56, no. 2 (201), pp. 57–73, 2015. doi:10.5604/0860889X.1172074. PDF.
- R. Kiciński and B. Szturomski, "Pressure wave caused by trinitrotoluene (TNT) underwater explosion — short review," Applied Sciences, vol. 10, no. 10, 3433, 2020. doi:10.3390/app10103433.
About the author. Capt (Dr) Sunil Tyagi, Indian Navy (Retd), is the founder and principal of Oravont Systems LLP. For six years he headed the Acoustic Stealth Group at the Directorate of Submarine Design, Naval Headquarters. Profile, CV and publications: suniltyagi.in.