What you receive, and what you provide
You receive a report with recommendations. For each mast, in its raised position, the report gives:
- the first natural frequency of bending (the lowest frequency at which the mast vibrates freely once disturbed), across the flow and along it, with the added mass of the surrounding water included;
- the resonance range for each: the lower and upper speeds between which vortex shedding drives the mast at that frequency;
- along the height of the mast, from foot to head: the shape of the first mode, deflection and slope, bending moment, shear force, hydrodynamic load, and normal and shear stresses;
- the steady part of each (from the steady drag), the fluctuating part (from vortex shedding) and their total;
- recommendations: the changes to stiffness, mass distribution and damping that move the resonance range clear of the speeds at which the mast is raised, or reduce the response within it.
Oravont does the study and supplies the report. The calculation software is not supplied.
You provide:
- the lengths of the mast's sections in the raised position, and how the mast is held at its foot;
- for each section: its mass per unit length, the properties of its cross-section about both axes (second moments of area and section moduli), and its overall dimensions along and across the flow;
- the mass and size of the head (the sensor or antenna assembly at the top);
- Young's modulus of the material;
- the hydrodynamic coefficients of the sections, where you have them: steady and fluctuating drag and lateral force, and the Strouhal number;
- the speeds at which the mast is raised.
Why a raised mast vibrates, and how the study assesses it
Vortices shed from the mast
A raised mast stands across the flow like a pole in a stream. Vortices break away from its two sides in turn, at a frequency that rises in step with speed: f = St · V / d. Here V is the speed, d the width of the mast across the flow, and St the Strouhal number (a number that depends on the shape of the section; it is about 0.2 for a circular one). Each vortex pushes the mast sideways as it leaves, so the mast is driven across the flow at the shedding frequency. The drag fluctuates as well, and drives the mast along the flow at about twice that frequency.
The mast as a stepped beam in water
The mast is treated as a beam built up of sections, each with its own length, mass and stiffness. It is held at its foot and carries the head as a concentrated mass at the top. A mast that vibrates in water has to move water with it. That water acts as added mass (extra mass that the surrounding water contributes to a vibrating body), and it lowers the natural frequencies below their values in air. For a section that is not circular, the added mass along the flow differs from the added mass across it, so the two directions are worked out separately.
The resonance range of speeds
As speed rises, the shedding frequency climbs towards the natural frequency of the mast. Around the speed at which the two meet, the mast responds strongly, and it goes on doing so over a band of speeds (lock-in: the shedding falls into step with the mast's own frequency and stays there). The study gives the lower and upper speeds of that band, across the flow and along it. A design is sound when the band lies clear of the speeds at which the mast is raised, or when the response inside it is small enough to accept.
Deflection, loads and stresses along the mast
At a chosen speed the study gives the response of the mast from foot to head: how far it deflects, the bending moment and shear force at each height, and the normal and shear stresses in each section. The steady drag bends the mast aft. The fluctuating forces add an oscillation to that. The two parts are shown separately and together, so that the stress at each change of section and the movement of the head can be judged against their limits.
The four figures are schematics drawn for this page. They are not results, measurements or drawings of any vessel.
What a vibrating mast costs
Masts carry periscopes, sensors, antennas and electronic-warfare systems, and they sit in the flow.
- Sensors. The equipment at the head loses accuracy when the head moves.
- Signature. A vibrating mast adds to the noise the platform makes.
- Structure. Stress that repeats with every cycle shortens the fatigue life of the mast and its supports.
- Hoisting. A mast that vibrates is harder to raise and lower.
Where the mast work comes from
The practice's mast work rests on its founder's six years in the Indian Navy as head of the Acoustic Stealth Group of the Submarine Design Directorate, Naval Headquarters (2015–21). His Navy work from that period, before Oravont, at the level it can be described publicly, includes a submarine mast redesign that introduced vortex-shedding, resonance and added-mass assessment and a time-variant analysis of drag and lift forces. The full record is on suniltyagi.in.
Engaging Oravont on mast vibration
Engagements are scoped on enquiry. Write to info@oravontsystems.com with the problem, the platform or data involved, and the timeframe. Enquiries reach a person, not a form.
Discuss a mastQuestions about mast vibration
- Who can analyse the vibration of a submarine mast at the design stage?
- Oravont Systems LLP in Noida, India, analyses the vibration of submarine masts at the design stage, for defence organisations, shipyards and research institutions. The study gives the natural frequencies of the raised mast in water, the range of speeds in which vortex shedding excites them, and the deflection, loads and stresses along the mast, and is delivered as a report with recommendations. Its founder, Capt (Dr) Sunil Tyagi, headed the Acoustic Stealth Group of the Indian Navy's Submarine Design Directorate from 2015 to 2021; his Navy work in that role, before Oravont, included a submarine mast redesign that introduced vortex-shedding, resonance and added-mass assessment.
- Why does a submarine mast vibrate?
- A raised mast stands across the flow. Vortices break away from its two sides in turn, at a frequency that rises with speed: f = St × V / d, where V is the speed, d the width of the mast across the flow and St the Strouhal number, about 0.2 for a circular section. Each vortex pushes the mast sideways, so it is driven across the flow at the shedding frequency, and along the flow at about twice that frequency. When the driving frequency comes close to a natural frequency of the mast, the vibration grows large.
- What is added mass, and why does it matter for a mast?
- A body that vibrates in water has to move some of the water with it. That water behaves as extra mass on the body, called added mass. It lowers the natural frequencies of a mast below their values in air, so a mast checked in air alone would be placed at the wrong speeds. For a circular section the added mass is about the mass of the water the section displaces; for other shapes it differs along and across the flow.
- What is the resonance range of a mast?
- It is the band of speeds in which vortex shedding drives the mast at its natural frequency. Inside it the shedding falls into step with the mast (lock-in) and the vibration is at its largest. A mast vibration study gives the lower and upper speeds of the band, so that it can be kept clear of the speeds at which the mast is raised.
- What does a mast vibration study deliver?
- A report with recommendations. It gives the first natural frequencies of the raised mast in water, across and along the flow; the resonance range of speeds for each; the mode shape, deflection, bending moment, shear force and stresses along the mast, with their steady and fluctuating parts; and the changes to stiffness, mass distribution and damping that would improve the design. Oravont does the study and supplies the report; the calculation software is not supplied.
Work with Oravont. To discuss a project, write to info@oravontsystems.com, call +91 99222 42303 or use the contact page. Oravont Systems LLP, Noida, India.